Jury Delivers $23.9 Million Verdict in Medical Error Lawsuit

Tittle Law Firm
Ohio Medical Malpractice Guide

This guide is intended to help you understand the proper steps to take if you think you might be the victim of medical malpractice in Ohio. If you still have questions please contact our office today for a free case review.

    medical error lawyerOn January 25, 2014, Anna Scott and Zachary Burke arrived at Jefferson Healthcare hospital in Port Townsend, Washington to experience what was supposed to be one of the happiest days of their lives- the birth of their baby girl.

    However, the events and medical errors that ensued at Jefferson Healthcare throughout the next 24 hours would leave Anna and Zachary emotionally scarred and Lana, their new baby, with permanent brain damage.

    The Claim

    The lawsuit filed on behalf of Anna and Zachary claimed that doctors and nurses at Jefferson failed to recognize critical signs with electronic heartbeat monitoring technology that showed the baby was in distress.

    According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, “Fetal heart rate monitoring is the process of checking the condition of your fetus during labor and delivery by monitoring your fetus’s heart rate with special equipment.” Such monitoring may help detect changes in the normal heart rate pattern and determine whether further action needs to be taken to treat a problem if one arises.

    The claim recognized that the medical professionals at Jefferson used a fetal heart monitor during delivery, but failed to realize it was picking up the mother’s heartbeat instead of the baby’s for over three hours.

    This failure led to the medical team’s assumption that the baby was in a healthy state when in reality, she was in severe distress.

    Permanent Brain Injury As a Result of Medical Error

    Before delivery, Lana, the couple’s daughter, had the umbilical cord wrapped tightly around her neck, depriving her of oxygen. She was born blue and needing extensive resuscitation just to be able to breathe on her own.

    Although there were plenty of opportunities for the medical team to recognize critical issues, Lana suffers permanent brain damage that will limit her mental and physical capabilities for the rest of her life.

    One way the damage could have been avoided, according to medical experts, was if medical staff would have taken the mother’s heart rate separately and compared it to the fetal strip throughout her labor. If they would have followed this simple step, the medical professionals on staff would have realized that the heart rates were identical, confirming possible confusion and distress.

    Robert Gellatly, one of the lawyers representing the family, claimed the damage could have been avoided if she had been delivered hours earlier by Cesarean section upon realizing the distress.

    The Trial

    The claim was originally filed in October 2016 but did not go to trial until November 4, 2019, concluding on December 20, 2019.

    The trial went on for seven weeks in front of a 12-member jury in Washington before rendering a verdict of guilty to find Jefferson Healthcare negligent in their duties, leading to severe, permanent injury to the child.

    According to court documents, the jury awarded a total of $23.9 million to the family, broken down as:

    • $10 million in necessary non-medical expenses
    • $6.25 million for non-economic damages
    • $2 million for medical care, treatment, and services
    • $1 million for lost earnings and earnings capacity
    • $2.3 million to Anna Scott
    • $2.3 million to Zachary Burke

    Anna explained that she wanted other families to know about the hardships they’ve experienced with the hope of preventing it from happening to others. “Lana is such a blessing in our lives and has the most beautiful smile and heart, but she will need care for the rest of her life”, Anna explained, “this verdict ensures she has a financial safety net to sustain her for decades to come”.

    Cleveland Birth Injury Lawyers

    cleveland medical error lawyerHaving a baby is supposed to be one of the most joyous and exciting moments of a person’s life. Unfortunately, that isn’t always the case.

    Medical professionals have a legal and ethical duty to meet standards of care. When this duty is breached in the delivery room, innocent newborns may suffer the consequences. While some injuries may result from unexpected labor complications or unforeseen circumstances, others stem from neglect or malpractice from health care professionals.

    If you suspect that your child sustained serious medical issues caused by negligent medical professionals in the delivery room, it’s important to consult with an experienced birth injury lawyer for help.

    To talk to a Cleveland birth injury and medical malpractice attorney at Tittle & Perlmuter, fill out our contact form online or call our office at (216)-438-9647.

    Contact Us

      First Name *

      Last Name *

      Phone Number *

      Email *

      Tell us what happened *

      Cleveland Office:
      Tittle & Perlmuter
      4106 Bridge Ave.
      Cleveland, Ohio 44113
      (888) 604-9299
      Get Directions
      Chardon Office:
      100 Center St
      Chardon, Ohio 44024
      Get Directions
      Sandusky Office:
      308 W Adams St 2nd Floor
      Sandusky, Ohio 44870
      Get Directions
      Elyria Office:
      124 Middle Ave
      Elyria, Ohio 44035
      Get Directions